American Idol 4-3

[CocoinTX]

I thought they all did pretty well. Melinda still on top. Blake was very good too.

Haley and Phil in bottom last night.

Sanjaya................in the PITS! The judges are giving up on booting him.

[gemsab]

I predict Haley will go tonight!

[CocoinTX]

I predict your right! :D

[Kathy]

I really have my favorites for the first season ever. :wave:

I really like Blake and Melinda. Coming in on my list at #3 is Jordan.

[Traci1972]

i dont like sanjia i think he is bad dont know how he is till there.

[clogaholic]

My favorite is Melinda, with Blake & Jordan next. I wish that Sanjaya would sent home but I think that it will probably be Haley.

[YellowRoseTex]

I missed the last 3 performances because I fell asleep. However, those I did see I thought did a good job. I still do not get Chris R though. :shrug: I think Jordan is the most improved and of course Melinda sure can sing! She really feels the music. I still would like to see her step outside of the box and do something different.

Have no clue who is going home. My guess would be the bottom 3 would be Haley, Phil and ????? One can only hope it is Sanjaya.

[gemsab]

I cannot believe Gina was sent home............I thought for sure it would have been Haley. This year is sure filled with surprises!

[Traci1972]

I was in shcok that Gina was sent home. i like Phil Stacy and Jordin

[CocoinTX]

Gina was sent home??!!!!!!!! UGH She didn't deserve that. Well, we all know who SHOULD have been sent home. THat's not going to happen though. Haley should've gone. Phil needs to do something. I don't know what. He has a great voice, but he's just not memorable as Simon says!

I'd like to see Melinda doing something out of the box too. She's fantastic, but it's like she's not being challenged

Next week. Jennifer Lopez. Latin songs. YAY! LOVE IT! Maybe that will challenge her.

[Traci1972]

i dont like Sanjya at all.
i agree Phil has a good voice but would love to se him do something original. they are all good i think except Sanjaya i can not understad how he is still there. Thumbs down for Sanjaya.