Who is your favorite American Idol of all time?

[ckelley110105]

id have to say either carly smithson or david cook

[YellowRoseTex]

That's a difficult question. At this point, none from the current season are my favorite idol of all time. My faves from all seasons are: Bo Bice, Taylor Hicks and Clay Aiken. I am basing my judgement on how they performed during the season, not by record sales. Bo Bice was the first time I ever felt compelled to vote.

[clogaholic]

Carrie Underwood!